Hi Rachel,
Thank you for your feedback 💕 We're sorry to hear that Gelato wasn't the soft peachy pink you were hoping for. Our Gelato is described as a vibrant pink, so we understand it may have been brighter and more intense than you expected.
We really appreciate you sharing your honest thoughts, as it helps other customers know what to expect from this shade and helps us improve our product descriptions.
If you'd like some guidance choosing a polish that's closer to the soft peachy pink tone you had in mind, please feel free to reach out to our Customer Service team – we'd be more than happy to help you find the perfect shade ✨